Approach speed control: which aircraft do you slow first?
Speed control is not about making every datablock show the same number. It is a spacing tool. A good instruction creates the interval at a chosen point while still leaving the crew enough distance to configure and fly a stable approach. A late reduction may look decisive on the scope but achieve almost nothing before the aircraft reaches final.
Start with the interval, not the speed
FAA JO 7110.65 5-7-1 tells controllers to determine the required interval and the point where it must be achieved. Only then should a speed be selected. Aircraft do not change speed instantly: altitude, configuration and current speed all affect how much distance the change needs.
In an in-trail sequence that is compressing, the FAA gives two first choices:
- Reduce the trailing aircraft first, so it stops gaining on the leader.
- Increase the leading aircraft first, if it can accept the higher speed.
That does not mean “always slow number two.” If the leader is already near its practical approach speed, increasing it may be unrealistic. If the trailer is still clean and far from the runway, a modest early reduction may be the cleaner solution. The traffic picture and aircraft capabilities decide which option is useful.
Use specific, readable phraseology
Current JO 7110.65BB expresses assigned airspeeds as indicated airspeed. Below FL240, controllers use five-knot increments. A pilot complying with an assigned or published speed is expected to remain within plus or minus 10 knots.
| Controller intent | Phraseology example |
|---|---|
| Assign one value | “Delta three twenty one, reduce speed to one seven zero.” |
| Preserve flexibility above a floor | “Maintain one eight zero knots or greater.” |
| Cap the speed | “Do not exceed one eight zero knots.” |
| Use the fastest practical value | “Maintain maximum forward speed.” |
| Use the slowest practical value | “Maintain slowest practical speed.” |
| Change by an amount | “Reduce speed twenty knots.” |
A specific value is easier to predict than “best forward speed,” but the practical phrases are useful while a broad sequence is still forming. As the picture tightens, replace them with a value when exact spacing requires one.
Know the recommended arrival minima
JO 7110.65 5-7-3 provides recommended minimum assignments. Lower speeds can be used when there is an operational advantage, and the pilot must advise if unable. These are controller speed-control minima—not a substitute for aircraft limitations, charted restrictions or the pilot's safe approach speed.
| Arrival below 10,000 ft | More than 20 flying miles | Within 20 flying miles |
|---|---|---|
| Turbojet | Normally not below 210 kt | Normally not below 170 kt |
| Propeller / turboprop | Normally not below 200 kt | Normally not below 150 kt |
Do not carry the restriction too far
ATC must not assign a speed adjustment to an aircraft in a holding pattern, nor inside the final approach fix on final or a point five miles from the runway, whichever is closer to the runway. The rule is a cutoff for assigning speed—not a target point for finally solving the sequence.
By that stage, the aircraft needs room to configure and fly the approach. Build the interval on downwind, base or the earlier part of the arrival. On final, monitor what the earlier plan produced instead of alternating speed reductions and increases.
An approach clearance cancels the old assignment
An approach clearance cancels previously assigned speeds. If the assigned speed is still required after the approach clearance, restate it in the same transmission or issue a new adjustment when permitted:
If the speed is not restated, the pilot is expected to adjust as necessary to complete the approach. This is a common readback trap: a speed issued two minutes ago may still be visible in the controller's plan but no longer be part of the clearance.
Published speed and assigned speed are different layers
STARs may already contain published speed restrictions. When ATC adds an unpublished speed, make clear where it starts or ends. Use the matching termination phrase:
- “Resume normal speed” ends an ATC-assigned speed where no underlying published restriction applies.
- “Resume published speed” ends the unpublished assignment and returns the aircraft to subsequent charted speed restrictions.
- “Comply with speed restrictions” requires the charted restrictions on the procedure.
- “Delete speed restrictions” removes assigned and published restrictions, but never removes regulatory limits such as 14 CFR 91.117.
Speed and descent need an order
Turbojets can struggle to descend and slow simultaneously. When both actions matter, say which one comes first. The word “then” makes the priority explicit:
Choose the order that protects the plan. If spacing is already collapsing, speed may come first. If altitude is the immediate constraint and the interval is stable, descent may come first. Avoid issuing both without an order and leaving the pilot to guess which result ATC needs first.
Readbacks and “unable” are operational information
Check the callsign, exact speed, any “or greater” or “do not exceed” qualifier, and the fix where the restriction ends. If the pilot says “unable” or reports a higher minimum safe speed, rebuild the sequence; the pilot retains the prerogative to reject an excessive or operationally unsuitable adjustment.
ATC: “Delta three twenty one, maintain one seven zero knots.”
The correction is not always another speed. A vector, a longer downwind, a different landing order or a go-around may be the safer way to recover the interval.
Common controller mistakes
- Waiting for the targets to touch. A speed change needs time and distance to affect spacing.
- Slowing the leader while the trailer stays fast. That increases compression unless there is another part of the plan.
- Changing the same aircraft repeatedly. Alternating reductions and increases creates workload and an unstable profile.
- Forgetting that the approach clearance canceled the old speed. Restate the speed if it must continue.
- Assigning speed too deep on final. The FAA cutoff is a limit, not a planning technique.
- Using “resume normal speed” on a STAR with published restrictions. Choose the termination phrase that matches the underlying procedure.
- Treating “unable” as bad compliance. It is new information about what the aircraft can safely do; issue a workable alternative.
A five-minute Approach drill
- Start the free guided Radar shift or an APP/DEP session at KSAN.
- Find the fastest trailing arrival before the gap becomes critical.
- Assign one specific speed and watch whether the spacing trend stabilizes.
- Issue the approach clearance and deliberately restate—or release—the speed.
- Complete the Tower handoff, then review Sequencing and Efficiency in the debrief.
Related guides: How to vector for an ILS · Holding instructions and EFC times · VATSIM S1/S2 practice drills
Practise speed control on a live scope
The free Radar session puts multiple arrivals on the KSAN scope. Assign speeds, watch the spacing develop, clear the approach and complete the Tower handoff with spoken pilot readbacks.
START RADAR TRAINING